Seyfarth Synopsis: The New York Legislature has passed legislation (S3460) that would significantly expand employee access to personnel records. The bill would require employers to provide current and former employees with copies of their personnel records within five business days of a written request, notify employees when negative information is added to their files, and comply with new recordkeeping and anti‑retaliation obligations.
Both chambers of the New York Legislature have passed a bill (S3460) that would require employers to provide employees with access to their personnel records and impose significant new recordkeeping and disclosure obligations on employers.
If signed by the Governor, the law would take effect 60 days after enactment, leaving employers with a relatively short window to assess and update compliance practices. Under New York’s legislative procedure, the bill could remain pending for many months before being presented to the Governor for approval or veto, and there is no current indication of when that might occur.
Access to Personnel Records
The bill would amend the Labor Law by adding a new Section 210‑b which would require employers to provide employees with access to their personnel records upon request, subject to several key requirements:
- Timing: Employers must provide a copy of the personnel record within five (5) business days of receiving a written request;
- Cost: Records must be provided at no cost to the employee;
- Scope: The term “personnel records” is broadly defined to include records used, or records that may be used, in connection with an employee’s qualifications for employment, compensation, promotion, transfer, or discipline, including applications, evaluations, and disciplinary documents.
Employers would be prohibited from retaliating against employees who exercise their rights under the statute.
The legislation also would require employers to retain personnel records for at least three years after termination of employment.
The law would not supersede a Collective Bargaining Agreement where it provides substantially similar or greater access to personnel records.
Violations of these requirements would be subject to civil penalties of $500 to $2,500, enforceable by the Attorney General.
Notice of Negative Information and Employee Responses
The bill would impose a significant affirmative obligation on employers to notify employees when negative information is placed in their personnel file. Such notice must occur within 10 days, and employees must be allowed to submit a written statement disputing or explaining the information, which must be maintained alongside the record and provided to third parties when the record is shared.
What This Means for Employers
If enacted, S3460 would significantly change personnel record practices in New York. Employers should consider the following:
- Increased Administrative Burden. Employers will need processes to respond to personnel record requests within five business days.
- Expanded Documentation Scrutiny. Because employees will have ready access to personnel records, employers should anticipate increased scrutiny of performance evaluations, disciplinary documentation, and internal communications.
- New Notice Obligations. The requirement to notify employees of negative information within ten days will require real-time tracking of disciplinary and evaluative actions.
- Risk Associated with Record Content. The ability of employees to submit rebuttal statements may affect how personnel records are used in decision‑making and litigation, particularly when disclosed to third parties.
- Policy and Process Updates. Employers may need to revise policies, train HR personnel, and standardize practices to ensure compliance with access, notice, and retention requirements.
Conclusion
S3460 would introduce a comprehensive personnel records access regime in New York, aligning New York more closely with jurisdictions that provide employees formal access to their personnel records.
If enacted, the law will require employers to reassess how personnel records are created, maintained, and disclosed, and to implement new processes to meet statutory timelines and obligations.
We will continue to monitor developments and provide updates. Please reach out to the authors or your Seyfarth attorney with any questions.
“With approximately 900 lawyers across 17 offices, Seyfarth Shaw LLP provides advisory, litigation, and transactional legal services to clients worldwide.”
Please visit the firm link to site
