You are currently viewing Turning Social Enterprises into Social Movements with Teresa Chahine
image

Hosted by Blake Eskin

One perk of making podcasts for the Yale School of Management is that I also get to eat there. The lunch options in the cafeteria are tasty and healthy. But this time when I came to New Haven, I stopped downtown at a café on the ground floor of the Temple Street Garage. It’s a place called Havenly. The street is kind of bleak, but once you step inside there are colorful couches, a couple of women meeting in a booth in the back, and a chalkboard on the wall with a menu—Damascus bowl, Istanbul street bites, falafel wrap. The kitchen also produces an array of Middle Eastern desserts.

This one is Nutella asabe, which is made with Nutella, cashews, and dough and syrup.

Or tamriyeh. They’re about the size of a ping pong ball, made of dates and then filled with nuts and dusted on the outside.

With desserts this good, Havenly’s founders kept hearing that it had the potential to become the Ben & Jerry’s of baklava, the Tate’s Cookies of tamriyeh. But getting into millions of pantries isn’t what Havenly is for.

Today, Havenly’s mission is to build community power among refugee and migrant women. It has nothing to do with food, or baklava, or the coffee shop, or anything.

That’s Teresa Chahine. She’s working on a research project with Havenly.

To me, being from Lebanon, it feels like being in a coffee shop in the Middle East. It’s so wonderful.

She also runs the Social Entrepreneurship Lab, a course at the Yale School of Management, and she brings up Havenly as a case study, one that’s near and dear to her, of how a social enterprise can grow and change in ways that are so different from other businesses.

What we talk about a lot, my students and I, is that it’s not just the outcome that matters in social entrepreneurship; it’s also the process. And that’s where the values come in.

Today’s lesson is about putting the “social” in social entrepreneurship.

So, what is social entrepreneurship, and how does it compare to starting any other kind of business? Well, business is business, so in either case, you have to bring in enough revenue to cover your expenses.

But in commercial entrepreneurship, that revenue is often the end goal, right? It’s the bottom line in and of itself. And in social entrepreneurship, it is a means to an end. It is your way of sustaining the work of achieving the social impact that you want to achieve.

Another big difference: Social entrepreneurs don’t necessarily worry about the competition.

My colleagues who teach traditional entrepreneurship are thinking about, how do you put up barriers to entry? How do you achieve an unfair advantage? What is your competitive edge that will prevent others from achieving this? In social entrepreneurship, we’re trying to do the exact opposite. You want people to be able to replicate your model. Once you are able to demonstrate proof of concept, you want to collaborate rather than compete with others, because you’re not going to achieve your social mission on your own.

The language of business didn’t really have a word for this collaborative approach.

My students and I were musing about how the words “entrepreneurship” and “intrapreneurship” are pretty universally understood. Entrepreneurship is starting a new company, whether it’s for-profit or nonprofit; intrapreneurship is innovating within an existing institution. But there wasn’t really a word that captured the concept that you have to innovate beyond the boundaries of existing institutions. You’re not going to create social change one organization at a time. And so we jokingly started referring to this as “extrapreneurship,” and there’s a lot of ways that you can do that.

Teresa Chahine didn’t originally set out to be an advocate for extrapreneurship. In fact, she wasn’t really interested in entrepreneurship at all.

I studied public health in graduate school, and my doctoral dissertation was about social and environmental drivers of health. I thought that I was specializing in public health so that I could do something to make a difference in helping people get the things they need to be healthy. Instead, I found myself crunching numbers and running multi-level, multi-variable regression models. I realized that most people who go to public health school get trained in studying problems and not in creating solutions.

That’s how I got into social entrepreneurship; it’s very focused on, once you understand the problem and why it’s persisting, how can you actually do something about it? And what would it look like to mobilize resources in a creative and daring way to see the impact of your work? And I was really craving that out of grad school.

I felt that we needed it in our curriculum at my alma mater. So I talked to the curriculum committee and I said, “This is unacceptable. I’m learning about social entrepreneurship as I try to figure out what to do with myself after grad school, but it needs to be in our curriculum.” And they said, “OK, great. Why don’t you teach it?” And that’s how it started.

Now she teaches students at SOM who may or may not see themselves becoming social entrepreneurs.

I get some who come from the private sector who are going to go back and work in consulting or investing, and others who just came out of the Peace Corps or worked for a global health nonprofit or were a teacher in a public school. So it’s really a mix. I definitely always get students who want to be a hero, who want to start something just for the idea of being their own boss. And then I have a mix of people who are totally daunted and intimidated by this whole concept of entrepreneurship. Or maybe they hate capitalism and they’re just like, “I can’t believe I’m taking a course with the word entrepreneurship in the title.” But there’s something about the course description that makes them suspect this isn’t your typical startup course.

Whatever their expectations are, she gives them all the same warning.

The first day of class, I always tell them, “You’re going to fail. You’re not going to change any of the world’s problems. So just know that from the start. I’m removing that pressure off your back. What I want you to get out of this course is that no matter how ugly things get, you’ll always be able to find people out there doing amazing work and trying to make things better. And you get to decide to what degree and how you might be part of that.”

Chahine does not teach your typical startup course. But her students follow a design process, like many startups do.

We start with, what is wrong with this world that you would like to see different? Before you start coming up with ideas about how you’re going to change it, you just study the problem. Why does it persist? What are the root causes? Who’s affected? Who has worked on this before? What has worked and what hasn’t?

Next comes interviewing—some field research.

You go and you talk to people, or rather, listen to people, and understand how they’re engaging with this problem, what their lived experience is like, how they think it could change, and who’s already working on it. Then you get involved in existing efforts and see what you can contribute and what you can offer to those collective efforts.

Havenly was founded back in 2018 by a refugee from Iraq and a recent Yale graduate who speaks Arabic.

At first they were just creating baklava. They wanted to put women to work and it was called Havenly Treats. So they would make baklava and they would sell it in coffee shops all over New Haven.

At first, Havenly got involved in the Yale startup ecosystem.

They were given advice to automate and standardize and scale and get in every Whole Foods in the country. And they found themselves questioning the purpose. “Is our mission to sell as much baklava as possible, or is our mission to work in a really in-depth way with refugee and migrant women so that they become economically productive?”

Hence the café, which became a space for educating these women, for helping them develop their skills.

They have a six-month fellowship program where they train refugee and migrant women not only in the hard skills of working in the culinary industry, in the food industry, in the U.S. and helping them get jobs, but also in the more important skills that are needed to navigate life in the U.S., to do the internal work that it takes to create change in your own life and in other people’s lives. A lot of these women have been through so much trauma and they don’t come from cultures where you talk about trauma, and don’t really have the tools needed to process and heal. And so that has been incorporated—English language, transportation, everything.

You can’t find all this on the menu at Havenly, but that’s what’s really going on. Havenly also works with other groups, an example of the extrapreneurship Chahine and her students struggled to name.

It is about building community power. They go to City Hall and advocate for housing policy. They’ve created their own network called Sisters in Diaspora. They collaborate with other refugee and migrant communities, such as the Semilla Collective. Many of them have started their own businesses in New Haven and back home. One of them launched a social enterprise based in New Haven and her home state of Oaxaca in Mexico, doing activities related to women’s socioeconomic empowerment. They’re building this whole ecosystem of changemakers, and their mission has expanded over time.

Of course, people who support projects like Havenly often want an accounting of their impact or a way to measure whether it’s working. In fact, that’s how Chahine got involved. Caterina Passoni, one of the founders of Havenly, met me at the café and told me the story.

We were at a meeting at a conference at Yale about how to measure happiness, and it was being run by a psychologist who was talking about measures of happiness. Teresa and I started talking about how hard it is to explain to donors really what we do. We measure increases in income—how much is someone making before and after the program—but there are a lot of other elements of our success that are harder to quantify and to measure. That’s how Teresa started helping us on this research project to understand specifically, how do we understand changes in agenc, and choice?

So Havenly came up with three questions that they asked the refugee women before and after their fellowships.

One is, what do you imagine for yourself this year? Second, what are obstacles you see in the way of that? And three, how do you see community playing a role in that? It’s really interesting to see the answers before and after. What we’re measuring is women’s ability to actually plan for their lives and set goals for themselves. We see before, someone saying, “Oh, well, I love washing dishes and that’s my career path.” And then after she might say, “Well, I have a degree as a doctor from my country and I’m going to go to school and do this and that.” So that’s very practically measuring the impact we have on choice and on planning.

There’s also a measure around community and what kind of things we making possible in the community through our women. For example, we measure how many women take leadership positions in the community. They might be running an organization. We have a woman who just took a leadership role in her church. That’s showing us that they are not just finding a job, but they’re actually starting to transform their communities.

While providing support for these women to become leaders, Havenly also reconsidered the way the organization thought about its own leadership team. Chahine explains.

There is a way of innovating and designing “solutions” and creating social change that is extractive, colonial, “heropreneurial,” and we want to avoid that. We want to think about how we’re doing this. Are we doing this in a way that builds power for others? Are we doing this in a way that elevates and amplifies the work that’s already been done, probably for decades, in the community by lived experience leaders?

Most organizations will have one big boss, but not at Havenly.

Now there is no executive director; it’s a shared leadership model. Both co-founders and a third person now have equally senior roles. This shared leadership model reflects their values and their mission.

These values also shape how they think about their board.

Their alumni form committees that can hire and fire board members and executive leadership. It’s not one of those situations where the board is made of a bunch of privileged people and so is the executive director, and then the power trickles down. It’s the other way around.

Another key difference between regular business and social enterprise is how they think about where they’re going to end up.

Most people when they think about entrepreneurship, they think about the end game. Are you going to go public and IPO, or are you going to be exit and be acquired and make hundreds of millions of dollars? Those are usually the outcomes you’re going for unless you just want to run your own business for the rest of your life, and some people do.

That’s not usually the end game for social entrepreneurs.

In social entrepreneurship, it is sometimes possible to exit in that way, but in most cases you’re not going to be acquired and you’re not going to make someone rich. So what is the end game? What does exit look like, and what does success look like? It can look like many different things.

To illustrate this point, Chahine tells a story of a project called ColaLife.

ColaLife was founded by two development workers who were sent to Sub-Saharan Africa to work on HIV/AIDS in the 1980s. When they started spending time with people and talking to them, and most importantly, listening to them, they got the message, “Why do all you people care about HIV/AIDS when our children are dying of diarrhea?” The number one killer of children is diarrheal disease. Let’s focus on that first, and then we’ll get to HIV/AIDS. So they quit their development jobs and started a new organization called ColaLife, and from the very beginning their goal was to shut down their organization one day.

The founders of ColaLife were thinking like extrapreneurs.

They recognized that colonial context—that they’re British aid workers working in sub-Saharan Africa—and so their goal was to build an ecosystem. Who are the existing players that are concerned about death among children under five from diarrhea? What are the solutions?

The solution in that case was so simple. It’s something called oral rehydration salt. It’s so cheap and so easy. Their innovation was co-packaging the oral rehydration salt and zinc therapy and finding ways to distribute it using retail channels. That’s why it’s called ColaLife; initially they said, “How come you can get a Coca-Cola in every village in Africa, but you can’t get access to basic essential medicines?” The problem was infrastructure—health clinics had poor inventory and were underfunded and hard to get to and not reliable. Their first innovation was that they designed pods that they would put in the space between Coca-Cola bottles in Coca-Cola’s crates, and deliver the oral rehydration and zinc co-packaging to the mom-and-pop shops where people bought their sodas.

That specific idea didn’t turn out to be the winning formula, but the concept of distributing at retail outlets did, and that’s how now you can get oral rehydration salts anywhere. It’s saved a lot of lives. Most importantly, over the years they’ve worked to understand the existing systems, and how can this be integrated into them so that they can make their exit. Earlier in our conversation, we were talking about exiting in a commercial way. The way they exited was that they built an ecosystem. There’s now an alliance called ORSZCA, the Oral Rehydration Salt and Zinc Co-Packing Alliance. When you go to the ColaLife website they say, “This organization has shut down. Please visit the ORSZCA website.” Their co-packaging guidelines and recommendations have now been written into the World Health Organization national guidelines for over 20 countries, and the work is continuing without them.

That’s ecosystem entrepreneurship, and it’s a great example of extrapreneurship and how to do things in a less colonial way.

Writing themselves out of the equation might have been the right answer for ColaLife, and Havenly has been evolving too. Since my visit, Havenly closed its café, which they said was too much to run on top of a job training program. Instead of working in the café, women on the Havenly fellowship will get experience somewhere else. Havenly might be leaving sweets behind, but they don’t need a café to build community power for refugee and immigrant women. And from an extrapreneurial perspective, they’re finding new partners who enable them to further their mission.

I think it’s important for Havenly to continue existing as an organization. I hope over the generations that it will be run by alumni and daughters of alumni, and that it will give birth to hundreds, if not thousands, of small and medium enterprises, or successful jobs led by these women in existing organizations, and that it will continue to be the sand that irritates the oyster and creates the pearl.

Meanwhile, Chahine is making her own pearls of wisdom more accessible through the online learning platform Coursera.

When I published the second edition of my textbook, Social Entrepreneurship: Building Impact Step by Step, I realized that it’s published by an academic publisher, it costs a fortune, most people can’t afford it, and I need to practice what I preach. I asked myself, how can I increase access to this book? I realized I can do it through videos. I can do it through Coursera. I can literally tell people what’s in this book. It’s basically a copy of the course I teach in person at Yale. So anyone, if they have internet, can take this course.

That was my motivation, and now it feels complete and I’m moving on. And that’s why I’m pitching this new course about applying a social innovation lens to social movements, and I’m moving more and more away from the startup world and more and more towards this concept of extrapreneurship, collective action, working with others.

Maybe it’s the effect my students have had on me over the past seven years at SOM, but I’m asking myself questions like: Why are we using capitalistic terms like entrepreneurship to describe solving problems that were created by capitalism? Why do we have such an individualistic model, where each person has this weight on their shoulders of designing and implementing and scaling these programs? Isn’t what we need actually to return back to the lost wisdom that our ancestors had of caring for each other and for the planet? How can we use that mindset to be more creative and daring about solving social problems? That’s the direction that my work is going in, and it’s really been informed in a very surprising way by the discussions and the reactions I’ve had with students at Yale School of Management.

Hundreds of years ago, the stock exchanges in London and New York grew out of coffee houses. A different mindset has been percolating in places like Havenly, enterprises that are guided by a social mission that focus on processes consistent with those goals, that collaborate with like-minded institutions on creative solutions to challenging social problems. Perhaps one day people will be able to look back and say of social entrepreneurship that it all comes back to baklava.

“The Yale School of Management is the graduate business school of Yale University, a private research university in New Haven, Connecticut.”

Please visit the firm link to site


Corporate, Tax, Legal, Wealth Management by Totalserve
Cloud, Data, Colocation, Cybersecurity by CL8
Audit, Accounting, Payroll by PGE&Co

Contribute and send us your Article.


Interested in more? Learn below.