Court of Appeal confirms distinct evidentiary rules in criminal vs civil Charter cases
BLG was recently successful at the Court of Appeal for Ontario in McCormack v. Evans, 2025 ONCA 767. McCormack was a unanimous decision, upholding the dismissal at trial of the plaintiff’s action against several police defendants, including claims for negligent investigation, malicious prosecution, misfeasance in public office, and Charter damages. Finding no error in the trial judge’s reasoning, the Court reaffirmed and clarified how judges must approach questions of evidentiary…

